Dário Moura Vicente (Universität Lissabon): Investment Arbitration – Lost in the Bermuda Triangle of EU Law, Public International Law and Private International Law?

Aktuelle Forschung im Internationalen Privatrecht

  • Datum: 07.03.2023
  • Uhrzeit: 11:00
  • Ort: Online-Veranstaltung
About the speaker:
Dário Moura Vicente is a Full Professor at the Faculty of Law of the University of Lisbon, where he has taught, over the past 30 years, among other subjects, Comparative Law, Private International Law, International Commercial Law and Intellectual Property Law. He is the Chair of the Portuguese Arbitration Association and was a member of the Drafting Committee of the Portuguese Law on Voluntary Arbitration of 2011. Among his publications are: Direito Internacional Privado: Ensaios (four volumes, Almedina, 2002-2018); La propriété intellectuelle en droit international privé (Brill, 2009); Direito Comparado (two volumes, Almedina, 2017-2018); and Comparative Law of Obligations (Edward Elgar, 2021).

About the topic:
Over the past decades, investment arbitration has been a fundamental mechanism for the settlement of disputes between States and foreign investors, which contributed significantly to enhance the protection of foreign investments vis-à-vis host States and strengthen the rule of law in international trade.
However, with the EU Court of Justice’s rulings on the Achmea, Komstroy and PL Holdings cases, rendered between 2018 and 2021, serious doubts arose in respect of the compatibility of International Law provisions concerning investment arbitration and the law of the European Union.
This has led not only to the termination of intra-EU bilateral investment treaties, but also to intense litigation regarding the arbitrability of claims brought by investors of EU Member States against other Member States and the jurisdiction of arbitral tribunals established under multilateral agreements, such as the Energy Charter Treaty.
Differing decisions, emanating inter alia from French, German, and Swedish courts, have been recently rendered in cases in which intra-EU arbitral awards concerning investment disputes were challenged before them.
This presentation will aim at giving an overview of the problem and of the different approaches to solving it in light of EU Law, Public International Law and Private International Law.

Zur Vortragsreihe:
Die Veranstaltungsreihe „Aktuelle Forschung im Internationalen Privatrecht“ wird von Ralf Michaels und Michael Cremer organisiert. Gastreferent*innen und Mitarbeiter*innen des Instituts stellen hier ihre Arbeit zu aktuellen Forschungsfragen und Entwicklungen im Internationalen Privatrecht zur Diskussion. Die Workshops richten sich an Wissenschaftler*innen, die zum Internationalen Privatrecht forschen und sind gleichzeitig offen für alle Interessierten aus dem akademischen Kontext (Doktorand*innen und Student*innen eingeschlossen).
Zur Redakteursansicht