Identity-Based Legal Categories and Jurisdiction in Egypt’s Mixed Courts
Research project
In the 19th and 20th centuries, Egypt was a semi-autonomous Ottoman province under both British occupation and significant French political influence. A person’s identity was of paramount importance during this time because of international treaties, signed between the Ottoman Empire and various European countries and known as the Capitulations, that determined rights and privileges (or lack thereof) accordingly: nationals of European signatories to the Capitulations were granted extensive legal privileges across Ottoman territories, including Egypt; an individual’s rights, obligations, and even access to certain judicial institutions depended on how they were legally categorised.
This identity-based framework shaped the establishment of the Mixed Courts of Egypt and their rules on personal jurisdiction. Competent only when a foreigner was a party to the litigation, the Mixed Courts institutionalized a native/foreigner dichotomy rooted in the Capitulations. As a result, a person’s classification into one of these two categories determined which courts they could access in Egypt.
But who was a “foreigner”, and who was deemed a “native”, a term not necessarily synonymous with “Egyptian”? Whether someone is foreign is usually defined negatively, by first determining who is native. But this was not the case in the Mixed Courts of Egypt. This project documents and analyses how identity was conceived of and operationalized in the Mixed Courts’ framework of personal jurisdiction. It demonstrates that the identity-based legal categories constructed under the Capitulations centred on specific conceptions of “indigeneity” and “Europeanness” that were neither natural nor self-evident but instead were legally as well as politically contingent.